Showing posts with label Reading Notes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Reading Notes. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 10, 2009

Notes on Chapter 9 - Economic Fluctuations

Introduction

In the long run, the economy, measured by GDP, is constantly growing. You can see the long-term GDP growth trend in the graph of US GDP from 1947 through the end of 2008.

However, if you look at the graph carefully, you'll see that there are short-term periods in which the economy grows at a slower pace, stays level or even contracts. These periods of falling real national income are known as recessions. Eventually, the economy recovers and continues on its growth path.

Short-run fluctuations in output and employment are often correlated and known as the business cycle.

In our study of economic fluctuations, we seek to:

1. Obtain a more complete understanding of the data, primarily GDP and unemployment rate, that are used to measure the economy and describe the short-run fluctuations.

2. Understand differences between short-run and long-run economic behavior.

3. Develop a model which can be used to describe and predict economic behavior in the short-run. We will call this model the AD-AS model and base it on the concepts of aggregate demand and aggregate supply which will be developed in our analysis.

Our ultimate goal is to understand the economic variables well enough to control the cycle of economic fluctuations through effective fiscal and monetary policies. We're not trying to eliminate the cycle entirely. That would likely be impossible. Rather, we are attempting to minimize the severity of the peaks and troughs in the cycle.

GDP, Unemployment and Okun's Law

Some notes on GDP:
Average annual GDP growth in the US is 3.5%.
Officially, the NBER Business Cycle Dating Committee determines when recessions begin and end.
NBER's rule of thumb is that a recession is defined as two consecutive quarters of declining real GDP. This is a rule of thumb and not a strict definition. Other economic factors are taken into account in the final analysis.

Note: It's unclear to me whether the rule of thumb is defined by declining growth in GDP or by negative growth in GDP. I.e. is it enough for the growth to be slowing down, or does the growth rate have to actually be less then zero?
Another interesting question is whether we compare GDP growth from quarter to quarter or from one quarter to the same quarter 4 quarters ago. The later method would take into account seasonal changes to some degree.

GDP = Y = C + I + G + NX

So we might expect all the components of GDP to decline during a recession. That is the case for consumption (C) and investment (I). However, we find that recessions have a more dramatic impact on investment (I = equipment, structures, housing, inventories, etc) than on household consumption (C).

Some notes on unemployment:
During recessions, unemployment generally increases. Economic growth slows when more workers are unemployed. The unemployment rate is related to the decline in GDP by Okun's Law:

%ΔGDP = 3.5% - 2 x Δ%Unemployment
This formula essentially means that the economy, measured by GDP, will grow by 3.5% when the unemployment rate is stable. If unemployment increases, GDP will drop by 2% for every 1% that unemployment increases, and vice versa.

Edward S. Knotek, an economist at the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, has written an interesting article entitled How Useful is Okun's Law?

Friday, November 28, 2008

Notes on Chapter 14 - Stabilization Policy

Chapter 14 - Stabilization Policy

We learned about the business cycle in Chapter 9. We also learned about shocks to the economy, both demand shocks which shift the aggregate demand curve and supply shocks which shift the aggregate supply curve. We also discussed ways in which policymakers can react to these shocks in order to dampen their effects and return the economy to natural levels.

In this chapter, we discuss stabilization policy in more detail to answer some fundamental questions about how government policymakers should respond to the business cycle:

  1. Should monetary and fiscal policy take an active role in trying to stabilize the economy, or should policy remain passive?
  2. Should policymakers be free to use their discretion in responding to changing economic conditions, or should they be committed to following a fixed policy rule?
Should Policy Be Active or Passive?

Monetary and fiscal policy have a significant impact on aggregate demand, inflation and unemployment. Use of monetary and fiscal policy to stabilize the economy is relatively recent, beginning with the Employment Act of 1946. Economists differ in their opinions as to whether government should actively use policy to stabilize the economy or whether they should take a hands-off approach.

There are three major criticisms of active government intervention in using monetary and fiscal policy to stabilize the economy:

  1. Lags in the Implementation and Effect of Policy
  2. Difficulty in Economic Forecasting
  3. Lucas Critique
Policy Implementation and Effect Lags. Implementation lag, also called inside lag, occurs when there is a lag in time between the economic shock and the implementation of policy. This lag occurs because it takes some time for economists to recognize the shock and for government to implement the policy. Policy effect lag, also called outside lag, occurs when there is a lag in time between the implementation of a policy and the effect that it has on the economy. Both inside and outside lag can be long and variable in length.

Fiscal policy suffers from a long inside lag because it takes a significant amount of time for Congress to pass legislation that affects taxes or government spending. Mankiw recently posted an article that noted that changes in fiscal policy, specifically through government spending, also suffer from an inside lag between the time the policy is passed by Congress and when it is implemented by the funds becoming available.

Although the central bank can adjust its policies quickly, monetary policy suffers from a long outside lag. Changes to money supply and interest rates influence investment and aggregate demand. Since many investment decisions are planned in advance, changes to monetary policy generally have a lag of about 6 months before their effect is felt in the general economy.

Automatic stabilizers are policies which stabilize the economy automatically without any changes to monetary or fiscal policy. Examples of automatic stabilizers are taxes and transfer payments. Taxes increase when the economy grows and income increases, thus having a dampening effect on the growing economy. Transfer payments increase as unemployment increases and income falls, thereby having a stimulating effect on the economy.

Economic Forecasting is Difficult
Because of the outside lags noted above, setting economic policy requires governments and central banks to forecast economic conditions six months in the future or more. Economists use both leading indicators and economic models to forecast economic conditions.

By their nature, economic models are limited in their ability to predict the future. In this respect, they are similar to the models that weather forecasters use to predict the weather and are often inaccurate. Two examples are the Great Depression of the 1930s and the recession of 1982.

The Lucas Critique
Robert Lucas is a Nobel Prize-winning economist who is currently associated with the University of Chicago. Lucas developed a theory, known as the Lucas Critique, which posits that the economy is influenced by people's expectations and those expectations are influenced by economic policy. Therefore, the very act of changing economic policy may influence the economy to more or less of a degree than anticipated by economic models due to the effect of the policy change on the public's expectations. In order to account for these effects, economic models should be modified to account for the influence of policy on expectations and economic activity.

The History of Stabilization Policy
In trying to determine whether stabilization policy should be active or passive, you would think that we could look back at history and see whether active or passive policy has been more successful. A few reasons are given why historical review doesn't give us a definitive answer.

1. When examining policy failures, i.e. large shocks, it's not always clear which policy would have been better. For example, concerning the Great Depression, some economists believe that a more active policy would have been the best way to address the situation. Other economists believe that a passive policy may have avoided the Great Depression in the first place.

2. Some economists look at the long term economic data and note that the economic shocks after the 1930s, when Keynes's theory was published and governments started instituting active policy, have been much less severe than the shocks prior to that time. This would seem to point in favor of active stabilization policy. However, Christina Romer, a UC-Berkeley professor and currently nominated for Chair of the Council of Economic Advisors, has noted that since the 1930s we have been gathering more and better economic data. Therefore, it may just be that we have better data in recent years, not that the active policy has made the shocks less severe.

Recent Stability
Throughout the 1990s and 2000s the GDP growth and inflation have been relatively less volatile than in prior years. Mankiw attributes this stability to 3 factors:
1. The US economy is now more service-based which is more stable.
2. Shocks just happen to have been less severe.
3. Fed Chairman Greenspan's management of interest rates and money supply stabilized the economy.

Wednesday, April 9, 2008

Reading Notes - Chapter 2

The reading assignment for lecture 2 was chapter 2 of Mankiw. The chapter focuses on 3 economic indicators:

Gross Domestic Product (GDP) - reported by the Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA)
Consumer Price Index (CPI) - reported by the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS)
Unemployment Rate - also reported by the BLS

Gross Domestic Product (GDP)

The GDP is the total income of everyone in the economy or, equivalently, the total expenditure on the economy's output of goods and services. For the economy as a whole, income must equal expenditure. GDP measures the flow of dollars in the economy.

There are two types of quantities: stocks and flows. A stock is a quantity measured at a given point in time (e.g. amount of water in a bathtub). A flow is a quantity measured per unit time (e.g. amount of water coming out of a faucet).

More precisely, the GDP is the market value of all final goods and services produced within an economy in a given period of time.

Parse that definition:
Market value - to calculate the GDP, don't count the number of apples or oranges produced. Rather, calculate their market value according to the price of each and compute the sum.
Produced - the sale of used goods is not included in the GDP.
Final Goods and Services - the sale of intermediate goods is not included in the GDP; only final goods.
Produced - Even if not sold. If the product goes into inventory, it is still considered as part of the GDP. When goods are sold from inventory, the sale is added to the GDP, but the reduction in inventory is subtracted.
Produced - The GDP includes some "imputations". These are approximations include services which are not sold on the regular market place. These include housing "services" to homeowners, government services such as police and fire departments. No imputation is made for services for the use of goods other than housing. No imputation is made for household goods and services such as home-made meals. No imputation is made for the underground economy.

Nominal vs Real GDP

The GDP measured at current prices is called nominal GDP. The GDP adjusted for inflation is called the real GDP. In computing Real GDP, a base-year for prices is usually chosen and indicated when reporting.

The Nominal GDP divided by the Real GDP is called the GDP Deflator.

A better way to calculate Real GDP is with a chain-weighted measure. To measure real growth from year X to year X+1, the average prices for those two years are used.
Components of GDP

The four basic components of the GDP are:
Consumption - nondurable goods, durable goods, services
Investment - business fixed investment, residential fixed investment, inventories
Government Purchases - Federal military, Federal non-military, state and local (but not transfer payments like Social Security and welfare)
Net Exports - exports minus imports

GDP is often reported on a per capita basis.

Other Measures

Gross National Product
GNP = GDP + Factor Payments from Abroad - Factor Payments to Abroad

A factor payment from abroad is a payment from someone outside of the economy to someone within the economy. For example, if a US citizen owns a building in London and collects rent on it, those payments are factor payments from abroad. And similarly for factor payments to abroad.

Net National Product
NNP = GNP - Depreciation

(Net) National Income
NNI = NNP - Indirect Business Taxes

Personal Income
Personal Income = National Income
- Corporate Profits
- Social Insurance Contributions
- Net Interest
+ Dividends
+ Government Transfers to Individuals
+ Personal Interest Income

Disposable Personal Income
DPI = Personal Income - Personal Tax - NonTax Gov't Payments

GDP and other economic indicators are usually seasonally adjusted to eliminate the fluctuations due to predictable seasonal changes.

Consumer Price Index (CPI)

Inflation is the increase in the overall level of prices and is measured by the Consumer Price Index (CPI). The CPI is calculated by the "basket of goods and services purchased by a typical consumer" model. Chicken has a higher weight than caviar since people buy more chicken than they do caviar.

There's also a PPI - Producer Price Index - which measures the price of the basket of goods and services purchases by a typical firm.

CPI vs. GDP Deflator

GDP Deflator has all types of goods and services. CPI only has consumer goods and services.
GDP Deflator only has domestic goods and services. CPI has domestic and imported goods and services.
The GDP Deflator "basket" changes as the GDP changes. It's a Paasche index. The CPI "basket" is fixed. It's a Laspeyres index.

A Fisher index is an index that takes the average of a Paasche index and a Laspeyres index.

Problems with the CPI

Many economists believe that the CPI overstates inflation. Some of the problems are:

1. Substitution bias. Consumers may shift and their buying habits based on prices. The fixed basket of the CPI does not take this into account.
2. New goods don't come into the CPI quickly.
3. The quality of the goods is not measured by the CPI.

A 1995 congressional panel concluded that the CPI overstates inflation by 0.8 - 1.6 percent.

Unemployment Rate

The unemployment rate is calculated based on two surveys: The Household Survey and the Establishment Survey.

The Household Survey surveys 60,000 households and gathers responses on the number of people in each household who are employed (anyone with a job), unemployed (anyone without a job but looking for one) and "not in the labor force" (anyone without a job and not looking - students, retirees, homemakers).

Labor Force = Employed + Unemployed

Unemployment Rate = Unemployed/Labor Force

Labor-Force Participation Rate = Labor Force / Total Adult Population

The Establishment Survey comes from the responses of 160,000 businesses about their payroll numbers.